On The Nightstand – Hammers On Bone – 9/3/2018

**Spoilers – Kinda**

I’ll start by admitting that this represents kind of a weird detour.  Right now, I have stacks of highly reviewed, well received books just waiting to be read.  My TBR list is a joke right now – it represents more of a retirement project these days than it does any realistic reading plan.

Nevertheless, I’m taking a digital walk-about on Amazon yesterday, right after finishing a post on “Ravencry” by Ed McDonald, and this under the radar title catches my eye.  Maybe it was the odd cover art…maybe it was the price at $3.99…most likely it was the Lovecraftian element.  I’m a sucker for all things Lovecraft and it doesn’t take much to convince me to download a new title.  Since the beginning of the year, I’ve read six books based on Lovecraft’s Cthulhu’s Mythos:

  • “The Ballad Of Black Tom” by Victor LaValle
  • “Lovecraft Country” by Matt Ruff
  • “Carter & Lovecraft” and “After The End Of The World” by Jonathan L. Howard
  • “Sherlock Holmes And The Shadwell Shadows” and “Sherlock Holmes And The Miskatonic Monstrosities” by James Lovegrove

All great reads that I’d highly recommend if you enjoy a good Lovecraftian themed story.

Short to long – I hit the Kindle Buy Now button and opened it up.  It’s a novella coming in at about 100+ pages and it’s a quick, easy, pretty entertaining read.

It’s a quirky story.  The author doesn’t waste any time on developing his character – by the end of the book, you still don’t really know who or what John Persons actually is – only that he’s a Lovecraftian monster in his own right – possibly the last Yithian left on Earth.  There’s no real world building – the story is set in modern day London and takes place in a working class neighborhood.  The language is a bit odd – set in the U.K. – but Persons uses terms like “dame” and “skirt” to describe women – leaving you feeling like Mike Hammer might be lurking somewhere in the shadows.  There are no higher causes – John Persons is just doing a job and is not worried about the evidence of larger problems that come to light during his investigation – though in the final chapter, he does make it a point to remind himself that he did “we did good” – the “we” being both the Lovecraftian monster that speaks to us throughout the story and the human body he animates.  There’s really no one to root for here – the two young boys that have hired John to kill their step father – also possessed by a monster – are really only using him as bait to draw out said step father / monster.  In fact, they eventually wind up selling themselves to Shub-Niggurath – one of the Lovecraftian Old Ones – to guarantee their protection.  It’s a dark, nasty story.

Having said that, I really enjoyed it – enough to buy all three of Cassandra Khaw’s novellas – another John Persons story called “A Song For Quiet” – and her two Rupert Wong books – “Cannibal Chef” and “Rupert Wong And The Ends Of The Earth”.  Khaw’s fresh and interesting and I’m very interested in seeing where she goes with her writing.

Posted in On The Nightstand | 2 Comments

On The Nightstand – Ravencry – 9/2/2018

“To Everyone Who Thinks Writing A Sequel Should Be Easy Because You’ve Already Created The Universe:  Bwa Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha! Heh. No.”

John Scalzi

This has been a good year for Grimdark.  A fair amount of my reading time has gone into the new entrants in this sub-genre and I’ve honestly only scratched the surface with respect to the 2018 releases.  I’ve read and reviewed R.F. Kuang’s “The Poppy War’ – which most seemed to really enjoy but which I found to be mediocre at best.  I read and reviewed Cameron Johnson’s “The Traitor God” and “The Grey Bastards” by Jonathan French – two really good books that I truly enjoyed but tagged with the “Missed It By That Much” Maxwell Smart quote for a few minor things that I called out in my reviews.  I read and reviewed “The Wolf” by Leo Carew – another book that I truly enjoyed and would have ranked higher than either “The Traitor God” or “The Grey Bastards” if I assigned rankings.  As good as most of those books were, however, my personal favorite – by far – was “Blackwing” by Ed McDonald – reviewed here:

http://booksofbrian.com/on-the-nightstand-blackwing-ravens-mark-6-17-2018/

and here:

http://booksofbrian.com/on-the-nightstand-blackwing-ravenmark-epilogue-6-18-18/

The reviews will give you an feel for how much I enjoyed this book – one of my favorites to date for 2018.  It therefore goes without saying that I was very eager to receive and read “Ravencry” – Book Two in the Series.  I picked this one up as soon as I finished The Wounded Land Trilogy and jumped in hoping for the same magic I’d found in the first book.  It never came.  It wasn’t a bad book – not by any means – I enjoyed it.  I still really love the world that McDonald has created, his protagonist continues to fascinate me and McDonald sets himself up for what looks to be a very interesting third volume.  Unfortunately, this one just didn’t explode in the same beautiful way that “Blackwing” did for me.

What happened?  Too many little things:

  • The writing wasn’t nearly as evocative and impactful.  The writing in Blackwing just dragged me along – it created some very visceral images and the protagonist’s observations on the world in which he lived and the people he interacted with were compelling.  The writing here felt a bit flat and I’m very sad to say that I wound up skimming at times.
  • The plot and pacing weren’t nearly as crisp and the book started slow.  I wasn’t able to put Blackwing down – reading that book was like rolling down a hill – it grabbed my interest immediately and the story just kept accelerating – never giving me a reason or a chance or any desire to stop or pause.  It was much harder for me to engage here and it took me far longer to finish that it should have.
  • There were a few parts of the book that just left me shaking my head – when the protagonist headed into the final battle in a mechanized set of plate armor and a phos-powered gatling gun – I honestly just stopped paying attention.  At that point, all I wanted to do was get to the end.

“Ravencry” was only published 11 months after “Blackwing” and I couldn’t help but think that McDonald didn’t take the time he should have on this one.  With “Blackwing”, it felt like McDonald had put everything he had into that book – obsessed over every single word and sentence.  Reading “Ravencry”, it felt like McDonald was grinding out a necessary but annoying Epilogue in order to deal with the consequences of an ugly but unavoidable decision the protagonist had made in “Blackwing” AND build the bridge to a critical third volume.

Please don’t get me wrong – this wasn’t a bad book – it was actually pretty good.  I enjoyed it every bit as much as “The Traitor God” and “The Grey Bastards”.  I’m still on board and I can’t wait for the third volume in the series.  McDonald creates some truly memorable, often uncomfortable moments during the story and his protagonist is every bit as hard – often unlike-ably so – and fascinating as he was in “Blackwing”.  It’s just that he gave me one of the better books I’ve read in quite a while with “Blackwing”.  I wanted more from “Ravencry” and I didn’t get it.  “Blackwing” was filet mignon while “Ravencry” was flank steak.

Posted in On The Nightstand | 2 Comments

On The Nightstand – The Wounded Kingdom – 8/26/2018

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

“Show Me A Hero And I’ll Write You A Tragedy”

F. Scott Fitzgerald

**Here There Be Spoilers**

I found these via a review of the third book – “King Of Assasins” – on one of the many blogs I follow – either Bookwraith’s or FanFiAddict’s – apologies for not remembering which – but I can recommend both of them to any Science Fiction and Fantasy fans out there.  These two gentlemen have guided me to quite a few really enjoyable reads over the course of the last 6 months.  If you’re not following them, you should.  The review of the third book was positive and left me interested in the series as a whole so I downloaded all three and spent the last week reading straight through.

I finished yesterday and, as I was thinking about what I was going to write, the quote above came to mind – and not for the reason you might think.  Anyone who’s read these books might think I’m referring to the way the series ended – I’m not.  I actually found the conclusion to be both satisfying and, in many ways, redeeming.  The quote actually resonated because I did find the hero in these three books to be a tragic one – tragically frustrating – and I’ll get to why in a bit.

I should start by saying that I did really enjoy all three books – I wouldn’t have continued through the series if I hadn’t – and I find it hard to say which I preferred – they were all solid and entertaining.  The overall premise was a good one, I enjoyed getting to know the world Barker has built – the idea of the Dead Gods, Festival, the juxtaposition of Assassin and Heartblade and the characters – particularly the characters.  Interestingly enough, the characters that most appealed to me were the secondaries – Merela (Girton’s Master), Aydor, Nywulf, Celot, Nimue, Crast, Gusteffa, Heamus, Neander, Tinia Speaks-Not, Rufra (Girton’s King and only true friend).  I found them all – at least some aspects of them – to be fascinating.  It’s impossible not to put Merela at the center of any affection you develop for these stories – she’s the calm, sane, center of every storm and she is – in the oddest way – the most caring parent you could ever hope to find.  The way in which the author transitions Aydor from hated, contemptible, bumbling villain to lovable, admirable, bumbling hero and friend is incredibly satisfying.  Nywulf is hero personified and is the hardest death in these three books full of death.  Tinia Speaks-Not, despite playing only a brief role in the third book is instantly likable.  The way Rufra grows from naive, idealist to capable, weary, experienced reformer king is extremely well done.  For me, it was these characters that carried the narrative through three volumes.

The protagonist – Girton – is another matter altogether.  He drove me nuts – from Book One straight through Book Three.  He’s emotional, quick to anger, barely in control of himself and always jumping to conclusions despite the very best advice from all of those around him.  He’s the one character in the books that manages to grow and mature the least – if at all – over the course of the three books.  Had Girton taken the time to reflect on his own preconceptions and prejudices and listened to those around him offering sound advice – Merela, Aydor, Nywulf, Rufra – fewer mistakes would have been made, multiple tragedies would have been averted and Rufra would have had a quicker and far easier climb to the High Kingship.

By way of example – from the second book – “Blood Of Assassins” – Girton’s decision to challenge and ultimately kill Karrick – the head of the Landsmen – in order to defend the herb seller who had been accused of sorcery and who would likely have identified both Girton and Areth as practitioners – was a pivotal point in the series.  Girton was advised repeatedly and vociferously by Merela, Aydor, Nywulf, Rufra AND Karrick – not to go down this path and yet he arrogantly chose to do so based on an assumption that Karrick had committed a murder in an earlier portion of the book.  As a result, he killed an innocent and relatively honorable man even after being cautioned repeatedly by numerous friends that he’d not conclusively proven the man’s guilt.  He also allowed a fanatic who hated Rufra and Girton to assume leadership of the Landsmen – ensuring that they would ally themselves with Rufra’s adversaries throughout the remainder of the story.

It’s easy to justify Girton’s decision as necessary to protect both himself and Areth from a similar charge of sorcery.  I couldn’t help but think, however, that an easier path presented itself – one that a clever and capable assassin would have seen immediately.  Heartless though it might have been, Girton should simply have killed the herb seller before the Landsmen had the opportunity to torture and interrogate her.  Girton had, by this time, traveled the assassin’s path for decades and had killed so many.  This would have been a small mercy for the herb seller, it would have allowed him to honor the command he’d received from Rufra and the advice he’d received from his friends and it would have resulted in an easier and less painful future for Rufra.  Most importantly, it would have shown some small measure of growth and maturation as a character.

This sad episode actually highlights another problem I had with Girton.  These books are, in part, a mystery.  Running through the three book narrative are multiple open questions that Girton is charged to answer – why was Neander collecting and protecting boys and girls with a potential to perform sorcery, who murdered Arnst and who is the spy and assassin present first in Mariyadoc and then embedded in Rufra’s court.  Frustratingly, Girton spends the better part of three books either failing to answer these questions or coming to incorrect conclusions.  Ultimately, it’s Merela – his Master – who unravels the mystery at the heart of the 1st book – “Age Of Assassins”.  Girton spends the second book coming to all the wrong conclusions regarding the murder of Arnst – causing chaos along the way and, as a result, almost clearing a path for two separate assassination attempts against Rufra – both of which he foils at the very last minute.  While Girton does finally identify the assassin / spy responsible for so much pain over the course of the three books, he does it only in the final chapters due to an off hand comment from Neander – information that should never have been that hard to obtain.  Short to long – this boy is not the Detective that I would want assigned to my case.

When you combine Girton’s impulsiveness and self-centered nature with the sheer amount of time he spends being wrong about so many things over the course of three books, I couldn’t help but wonder why either Merela or Rufra continued to tolerate him.  The longer I read – the further I progressed through the story – the more I began to feel that Girton was half the problem.  I would have finished the third book with a profoundly negative view of the character were it NOT FOR ONE THING.  In the final chapter of the third book, years after the events that gave Rufra the High Kingship, it’s revealed that Girton makes an exceptionally difficult, truly selfless decision which saves Rufra and his reign while dooming him to life as a hermit and exile.  For me, that final chapter finally gave me something about Girton to truly admire – it delivered the redemption he so desperately needed.

I’ll say again – I did really enjoy these books.  They’re a very worthy read.  I just wish Girton had been an easier hero to stomach.

Posted in On The Nightstand | 6 Comments

On The Nightstand – The Eternal Champion – 8/26/2018

 

“Time Moves In One Direction, Memory In Another”

William Gibson

I did something last week that I should probably never do – revisit an old favorite from my teenage years.  At that time in my life, I was enthralled with Moorcock’s Eternal Champion / Multiverse stories – Elric, Corum, Hawkmoon, Von Bek – could not get enough and read everything I could find and buy.  The books were important enough to me that I’ve spent years tracking down all 15 volumes of the hardcover special Omnibus Edition from White Wolf Publishing that collects every word Moorcock’s written about The Eternal Champion – a task I finished recently with a couple of final purchases.

Despite the collecting effort, I haven’t gone back to any of this work in years – I just lived off the good memories.  That changed last week.  I had just finished the final page of “Autumn In The Eternal Kingdom” by Stephen R. Platt – a long and hard but very rewarding read and I was desperate for a diversion.  I was poking around the library and – for no reason that I can explain – I fastened upon those 15 volumes and pulled out the first – a collection of 4 stories beginning with the origin tale of Erekose – titled “The Eternal Champion”.

Erekose is a unique and important incarnation of The Eternal Champion for several reasons.  First, he’s the only one of many Champions that actually has any awareness of both his other lives as well as the eternal cycle of war in pursuit of Order and Balance which he serves.  Second, in this story, he makes a choice that is morally correct but arguably in defiance of the purpose for which he’s called – leading to the suggestion that all other incarnations of The Eternal Champion are somehow punished for Erekose’s choice.  Finally – refreshingly – until he’s once again called – this is the only story in the cycle where The Eternal Champion achieves any degree of peace and happiness.  For the cycle, it has defining implications.

I’ll start by saying that I enjoyed the chance to step back into a body of work that I remember so very fondly.  It felt comfortable and fun and it left me wanting to push on and reread everything from beginning to end – experience it all over with older eyes.  The only problem is that I was forced to acknowledge that the writing just wasn’t all that good.  It was highly stylized – artificially archaic – a bit simplistic at times.  The concepts still appealed and I appreciated the story every bit as much.  I just couldn’t help being more judgmental this time around with respect to technical execution.  It didn’t kill the story for me and it didn’t damage the memories I have with respect to the work.  It just took a little bit of bloom off the rose.

I’m still a passionate Moorcock fan and I’ll always be thankful for what he did back in the 60’s and 70’s by giving us the Multiverse – we owe him for that and many have built on his work.  I read and enjoyed his most recent novel – “The Whispering Swarm” – and all of these books will always have a special place in my heart.  I do still plan to go back and reread more of these stories.  I just can’t help but feel a bit of sadness about the way my perspective has changed over the years – a very small bit of youthful enthusiasm lost to middle age.

Posted in On The Nightstand | 1 Comment

On The Nightstand – Autumn In The Heavenly Kingdom – 8/24/2018

“There Is Nothing New In The World Except The History That You Do Not Know”

Harry S. Truman

The America Civil War lasted for approximately 4 years – from 1961 to 1965  That war left 620,000 to 750,000 combatants dead.

The Taiping Rebellion lasted for approximately 14 years – from 1850 to 1864.  Estimates of the war dead from this conflict range from 20 to 70 million with some estimates as high as 100 million.

I was completely unaware of this chapter in Chinese history until I’d read “Autumn In The Heavenly Kingdom” and I suspect that most Americans would have to say the same.  Like most of us, I’d studied and read about the American Civil war and have been sensitized to the horror and the tragedy of this conflict.  Yet – in the same year that our Civil War began – the Taiping Rebellion was entering into its 11th year.  Over the course of that 14 year war, anywhere from 20 to 100 times the number of Chinese combatants and civilians perished.  I like to think of myself as a relatively well educated individual but that presumption is continuously put to the test by the simple act of opening a new book.  I was – quite honestly – astounded that I’d had no prior knowledge of a conflict that stands out as one of the bloodiest in human history, the single bloodiest civil war in human history and the largest conflict in the 19th century.  My thanks to Stephen R. Platt and this very well written book for opening my eyes and furthering my education.

This was the second step in my history walk-about – taking what I thought was a brief break from Science Fiction and Fantasy highway to do some more substantive reading.  I started with Stephen R. Platt’s “Imperial Twilight:

http://booksofbrian.com/on-the-nightstand-imperial-twilight-7-22-2018/

A superb history of the First Opium War – another episode in Chinese history with which I was only marginally familiar.  “Autumn In The Heavenly Kingdom” picks up about 10 years after the end of “Imperial Twilight” and touches on some of the ramifications of that conflict – particularly what it meant for the Western – primarily British – presence in China at the same time it chronicles the forces that would ultimately lead to the end of Qing Dynasty in the early 20th Century.

Where ‘Imperial Twilight” was a crisp and easy read, this one was far more challenging for me and it took far longer to finish – one of the reasons my posting has slowed over the course of the last two weeks – the others being an intense period at work and the bittersweet process of sending both of our children back to College.  I found “Autumn In The Heavenly Kingdom” to be every bit as well-written and exhaustively researched as “Imperial Twilight”.  It was a superbly constructed, narrative history.

Having said that, I suspect it was a far more difficult book for Platt to write.  This period in Chinese history was more complex and he was required to spread his narrative across the perspective of a far more expansive group of players and powers.  He was not only chronicling the Civil War between the Qing Dynasty and the Taiping Rebels – he was also describing a dynastic struggle that brought the Empress Dowager Cixi to power as well the foreign policy of the Western powers in China which began with the Second Opium War – a military expedition against the Qing Dynasty which resulted in the razing of the Old Summer Palace in Beijing – a cultural tragedy – and ended in a frustrating period of indecision as they swung back and forth between neutrality and – ultimately – active support of the Qing Dynasty.

There was a lot going on here and Platt tried to capture it all in a modest single volume – ambitious when you remember that Shelby Foote needed three massive volumes to record the history of the American Civil War – a conflict that lasted only a third as long and was – in some ways – more straightforward.  It’s a challenge that Platt acknowledged in his Preface when he wrote “This book is not a comprehensive history of the Chinese Civil War, which, given it’s enormous scale, would too easily devolve into a numbing list of dates, battles and casualties.  It is, however, an attempt to show the war from all sides, and to recapture a sense of what it was like to be alive at the time – both for the Chinese who were caught up in the conflict and for the foreigners who stood at the sidelines, traveled through it, and launched their own wars on top of it.”

While I struggled to finish this one – taking over 2 weeks to do so – I still found it incredibly rich, instructive and well worth the time and effort.  The narrative raises so many what ifs over the course of the story – the most significant being – how would the world we live in today be different had the Western Powers chosen to actively support the Taiping Rebels – an independent state within China that was arguably more aligned with the West in areas as diverse as economic / social / judicial modernization and cultural / religious philosophy.  Also interesting was the way in which Platt was able to tie events in China back to what was happening at the time in the Western Hemisphere.  Britain’s economy at the time was tied to a triangular trade that began in the Southern United States and their cotton exports, through the modern mill towns of England and Scotland that turned that raw cotton into cotton fabrics and then on to China, where those fabrics – along with Indian opium – were traded for tea and silks.  Britain found itself navigating the complexities of civil wars in the two countries that were, at the time, driving it’s domestic economy and the feeling of the Government at the time was that they were not adequately equipped to intervene in both conflicts.  This was partly the cause of it’s decision not to intervene in the U.S. Civil War on behalf of the Confederacy – a fact of which I’d been completely unaware until I’d read this book.

Finally, as a former Diplomat, I found the interplay between the British Government in London and it’s representatives on the ground in China to be fascinating.  During my time overseas, there was always some minor flexibility with respect to the way that U.S. policy was translated into diplomacy at the point of true impact.  Even in an age of instantaneous communication, there are always ambiguities in the guidance Embassies receive that are sometimes exploited or manipulated by the local Mission and the Ambassador.  During the time described in Platt’s book, when the communication cycle was measured in months and the ambiguities in guidance were far greater, I was fascinated by the liberties taken by the representatives of Her Majesty’s Government in effecting their government’s policies as well as their ability to influence the Government’s position with his own, unverifiable opinions.  Over the course of the narrative, it’s easy to see the damage caused by that willingness not to implement but to create policy based on the prejudices and beliefs of those distant representatives.

So… this one was a labor…of love…and well worth the time.  I would recommend both books to anyone interested in the period so long as you begin with “Imperial Twilight”.  I put over three weeks into these two reads and I’m very glad I did.  I suspect the best way to end the review is to quote Platt’s final comments in his Epilogue:

“If there is any moral at all to be gleaned from the outcome of this war, which brought so little of lasting benefit to either its victors or the country in which it was waged, it is not likely to be of the encouraging sort.  For, in a certain sense, the blame of the war’s outcome might be laid at the feet of our intrepid preacher’s assistant, Hong Rengan.  After a few years among the missionaries of Hong Kong, he believed that he knew the hearts of the British and could therefore be the one to build a bridge between his own country (the Taiping Rebels) and theirs.  This belief led him to advocate a policy of appeasement and openness toward foreigners that ultimately proved the ruin of his own people.  By the same token, blame could also be laid with the shy British Ambassador Frederick Bruce for imagining, after a short residence in Shanghai and Beijing, that the Qing dynasts were a force of civilized monarchy standing against a chaotic horde of rebels who had no king or governing vision – and on that basis, persuading his home government that it was necessary to intervene on behalf of what he thought was the only viable power in China.

Hong Rengan and Frederick Bruce had in common that each thought himself uniquely blessed with insight into what was good and knowable in the other’s civilization, and they also had in common that they were both grievously wrong.  So in the end, perhaps the tale of the foreign intervention and the fall of the Taiping is a tale of trust misplaced.  It is a tale of how sometimes the connections we perceive across cultures and distances – our hopes for an underlying unity of human virtue, our belief that underneath it all we are somehow the same – can turn out to be nothing more than the fictions of our own imagination.  And when we congratulate ourselves on seeing through the darkened window that separates us from another civilization, heartened to discover the familiar forms that lie hidden among the shadows on the other side, sometimes we do so without ever realizing that we are only gazing at our own reflection.”

I would challenge every reader to take that suggestion and apply it to the history of America’s interventions in local conflicts since the end of the Second World War – particularly Vietnam and Iraq – and determine for themselves whether it resonates.

Now – the good news for me is that – having satisfied my need to spend some time expanding my education, I’m free to shift my time back to my 1st love – Science Fiction and Fantasy.  I’ve spent the last few days digging into my backlog and I’ve managed to finish a number of titles that I’m looking forward to posting on.  Thanks to everyone for their patience while I’ve been away and spending time with weightier fare.  Now let’s have some fun. 🙂

Cheers

 

Posted in On The Nightstand | Leave a comment

On The Nightstand – The War In The Dark – 8/13/2018

“The Covers Of This Book Are Too Far Apart”

Ambrose Bierce

**Spoilers – Sorta**

This is going to be a tricky review for me because I’m going to take great care to keep from being too harsh.  I did finish this book and I did find it somewhat interesting and entertaining.  Having said that, the first chapter was so poorly written that I came very close to doing something I never do – close it and put it aside.  I did honestly stop at the end of the first chapter and entertain a brief internal monologue:  “Do I really want to put the time into this?  I have so many interesting books waiting to be read.  I still have to finish “Autumn In The Heavenly Kingdom.  What were Setchfield, his editor and / or his publisher thinking when they decided to go with this opening?”

Ultimately, I decided to give it a second chance and it did get better – marginally.  I can only assume that I decided to give it the benefit of the doubt because there’s another series rooted in the same general premise that I truly love – “The Laundry Files” by Charles Stross.  I was likely hoping that lightning would strike a second time – but – Nope – hardly a spark.  If you’re interested in the concept of a government sponsored National Security organization focused on the supernatural….Stop…Do Not Pass Go with “The War In The Dark”…progress straight to Stross.  Those books are very well written, well conceived, rooted in the Cthuhlu Mythos and they’re crazy fun/ funny.  This one…not so much.

It almost felt like the author just kept throwing random stuff into a blender to see what he’d eventually wind up with – a bit like “Uncharted” by Kevin J. Anderson and Sarah A. Hoyt.  Random demons…a male protagonist whose back story doesn’t really begin to develop until we’re halfway through the book…a female protagonist whose backstory is never really fleshed out…a character who’s ostensibly killed in very early in the book who reappears during the climax under the pretext of a faked death…a clandestine Soviet military facility in West Germany in the early sixties…Reliquarists…The Order Of The Leaf…John Dee and Edward Kelly….the idea of the Ascendence / Armageddon…the idea that the Fallen Angels would allow themselves to be led back into our world by the partial half-soul of a mortal – it’s all just kind of a hot mess.  Short to long – this is an ugly book – in tone and in execution.

I did finish and there were parts that I enjoyed.  I did appreciate the way both Vienna and Berlin were correctly described as epicenters of East – West espionage during the early years of the Cold War – very true.  I also appreciated the way the lingering destruction of WWII in the major cities of Europe was described – something else that rang true and that was artfully described.  Despite the lack of a true backstory, I enjoyed the female protagonist.  Sadly, though, there was too much mess and not enough nearly enough art.  There was a good story somewhere in here but it just wasn’t very well executed and I’m hoping that the author isn’t tempted to turn this into a series.  One was enough – at least for me.

Posted in On The Nightstand | 4 Comments

On The Nightstand – Fifth Ward: First Watch – 8/11/2018

So…how many times in Fantasy Novels does the author toss out a throw away line about the City Watch – almost always a nameless, faceless presence that’s mentioned in passing – included mainly for the purpose of setting the stage or because it’s an easily acceptable way to establish the atmosphere for a scene.  Here’s a novel idea – why not write a BOOK about those guys – and in the process make it fun freakin’ story – and let them be the heroes for once and not the guys that the heroes avoid, ignore, disrespect or put down with contemptible ease.  While we’re doing all that – here’s another neat idea – let’s make it a police procedural.

Dale Lucas has done just that and thanks to him for finally putting these guys at the center of the story.  Thanks also to FanFiAddict for pointing me in the direction of this book with his review of second book in the series – “Fifth Ward:  Friendly Fire”.  As I was reading this book, I couldn’t help but keep asking myself – why hasn’t someone done this before or, if they have, why didn’t I know about it.  I started this one Friday after work and I was done by about 3:00 on Saturday.  It was fast, fun and totally worth the price.  This is probably not a book that’s going to stand the test of time but it was still a real treat – just the thing I needed to break away from some of the heavier stuff I’ve been reading.

The two main characters, Torval and Rem, are an odd couple that works.  Rem may be just a bit too wide eyed and well-intended while Torval may be a bit too angry and formidable at times but overall, they’re well matched and, by the end of the book, they’re working well together as partners.  Rem toughens up and Torval softens and humanizes – odd thing to say about a Dwarf but true nonetheless.  I liked the way Lucas created his environment – the city of Yenara is a place that can, for its residents and its cops, easily become the object of a Love – Hate relationship.  The Ward (Precinct) approach is well-conceived and the way the non-human races fit within the legal system is unique and interesting.  The objects of Torval and Rem’s investigations start small and the larger crime is masked until the end of the book as the threads of those two investigations come together.  Magic plays a very small part in order to keep the focus on the police and the police work.  I really did  think the whole thing was well-constructed.

This one was a winner – Lethal Weapon with medieval weaponry – a book that I didn’t want to put down.  I’ve already purchased the second book and plan to jump into it as soon as I can.

Posted in On The Nightstand | 3 Comments

On The Nightstand – Rogue Protocol – 8/10/2018

I am very close to finishing “Autumn In The Heavenly Kingdom” by Stephen R. Platt – its been a longer journey than I’d expected – a good but slow read which I should be able to post on this weekend.  Still, this one arrived on Wednesday and it had to be read.

I’ll start by saying that I’ve read and reviewed the first two books in the series – first “All Systems Red”:

http://booksofbrian.com/on-the-nightstand-all-systems-red-1-16-2018/

It’s a book I enjoyed but wasn’t as enthusiastic about as most of those who’ve read it.

I also read and reviewed “Artificial Condition”:

http://booksofbrian.com/on-the-nightstand-artificial-condition-2-25-2018/

I actually thought this was the better of the two and it left me optimistic about the direction in which the story was heading.

Then comes this one and I’m left shaking my head a bit.  I’m going to start with this post where I ended my review of “Artificial Condition”:

“I honestly have only one complaint and it has nothing to do with the book itself.  I don’t like the way Martha Wells and the publisher are commercializing the work – hence the Razor / Blades quote.  The story is being sold as 4 separate novellas:

  • All Systems Red – 2017
  • Artificial Condition – May 2018
  • Rogue Protocol – August 2018
  • Exit Strategy – October 2018

They’re sold separately as hardcovers at the price of $16.19 and as e-copies for $9.99.  In reality, these are 4 sections of one book – obvious as you read through each separately – and could easily have been published in one volume.  The fact that they were all released within an 18 month period only confirms that the Author and the publisher made a pretty crass commercial decision to break the book into four pieces and sell them separately to maximize revenue.

Instead of paying $25 for a single hardcover volume, I’m forced to purchase 4 separate novellas for a combined cost of ~$68.00 in hardcover or ~$40.00 in digital format.  Before you say it, I will – shame on me – no one forced me to spend the money – I know I’m being played.  Nevertheless, I’m really enjoying the books and I want to get my hands on them as they become available.  It just leaves a bitter taste in my mouth and it makes me wonder about Wells’ attitude towards her fans and readers.  Wells and her publisher gave me the Razor but she’s selling me the blades – one at a time – at a pretty high price.”

The further I progress into the series, the more this frustrates me.  This volume picks up immediately upon the end of “Artificial Condition” – almost seamlessly.  It’s obvious that Martha Wells wrote this as a single volume and it should have been published as such.  I do feel exploited and a bit betrayed – not by the publisher – I understand and accept their business decision – but by the Author who could have forced a decision more in keeping with the interests of her readers.  There – I’m done – last time I’ll say it – until the 4th book is released.

If that were the only thing, we’d be fine.  It was an entertaining story and we get more of the same Murderbot that so many people seem to have fallen in love with.  Martha Wells serves up another type of Bot to serve as both ally and foil for Murderbot.  It’s a quick, easy, enjoyable read.  Even with all that, I can’t escape the feeling that something’s going a bit wrong with the story – and I think the problem – at least for me – is Murderbot.

In each Novella, Murderbot grows and his personality develops.  He defines himself through contact and cooperation with both new groups of humans, new types of Bots and new Machine Intelligences.  Murderbot really started to grow on me in “Artificial Condition”.  I enjoyed watching him rationalize his actions and I appreciated the way he connected with and related to both his human and machine acquaintances.  To be honest, I found him to be a little annoying in this book.  The personality traits he manifested made him feel to me like an odd combination of a grumpy old man and a spoiled teen.  I’m sure many – likely most – will find this to be intriguing and lovable.  It didn’t work as well for me.

I had a second, more wonkish problem and it’s one that’s been creeping up on me across all three novellas.  Murderbot doesn’t define very well for me as an entity.  There are many different categories of personhood in the book – humans, augmented humans, machine / human hybrids (like Murderbot), true bots (Miki and the Combat Bots) and artificial intelligences like ART from “Artificial Condition.  I’m struggling to find a rationale for the creation of an entity like Murderbot.  I continue to ask myself what the advantages of a hybrid entity like Murderbot actually are – incorporating biological vulnerabilities – particularly after the acknowledgement in “Rogue Protocol” that there are also Sec Bots that are even more formidable than Combat Bots.  Bots like Miki seem to have to capability to relate to and connect with humans.  Combat Bots and Sec Bots seem to be far more formidable combatants than Murderbot.  The only thing that really seems to separate Murderbot from augmented humans is the governor module that Murderbot has managed to hack.  I just don’t see how he fits in the larger scheme of things – what unique quality a SecUnit like Murderbot with a functioning governor module brings to the table.  There has to be a functional rationale for creation of an entity as complex and obviously expensive as Murderbot and I just don’t see it.

I know this won’t bother most but it stands out as a non-sequitur for me.  It doesn’t keep me from enjoying the stories – I have. It just keeps me from enjoying them to the same degree as other readers seem to – like an annoying itch that can’t be scratched.

Overall, this is a fun book and I suspect most will see it as a great addition to the story.  I’d recommend it to anyone who’s enjoyed “All Systems Red” and “Artificial Condition”.  I’m certainly going to buy and read the final installment – “Exit Strategy”.  I guess all this means is that the series is not going to make it to my top shelf and I don’t know how much staying power it’s ultimately going to have.

Posted in On The Nightstand | 4 Comments

On My Mind – Principiis – Six Mistakes Of Man – 8/4/2018

**Marcus Tullius Cicero, the great Roman orator who died in 43 B.C., recorded what he considered to be the six most drastic mistakes repeatedly made by man.**

The delusion that individual advancement is achieved by crushing others

The tendency to worry about things that cannot be changed

Insisting that a thing is impossible because we cannot do it ourselves

Refusing to set aside trivial preferences

Neglecting development and refinement of the mind by not acquiring the habits of reading and study

Attempting to compel others to believe and live as we do

**Some things never seem to change**

This is the third of my Pillars but – as always – I thought I should link back to the post that started the series:

http://booksofbrian.com/on-my-mind-principiis-7-28-2018/

I followed that with a post on my 1st Pillar – IF by Rudyard Kipling:

http://booksofbrian.com/on-my-mind-principiis-if-7-28-2018/

Followed by a post on my 2nd Pillar – Live A Good Life by Marcus Aurelius:

http://booksofbrian.com/on-my-mind-principiis-live-a-good-life-7-31-2018/

I’ve always kept Cicero’s Six Mistakes Of Man as the 3rd of my six Pillars and, as a result, this post represents the halfway point in the series.  This is one that came to be as a result of the time I occasionally spend reading works of classical history.  I stumbled across it in a biography of Cicero (quick note – something I learned from my son and step daughter – our two Latin scholars – his name is actually pronounced Kikero – the C in Latin always being pronounced as a K).  It captured and held my attention at the time because it seemed to hold up so well across the years – once again, there are no new problems.  It also  seemed to me at the time to be something that every single person should be required to study and debate at an early enough age to – just possibly – make a difference across the years of one’s life.

All of us move through life manifesting – often unconsciously – learned behaviors – both constructive and destructive.  While these six don’t – by any stretch of the imagination – encompass the totality of negative prejudices and attitudes that we all too frequently fall victim to – they’re likely not even the worst that you might call out – I can tell you that I see all six of these far too often – both in my own thoughts and behaviors as well as in those of others.  As a result, I’ve always tried to keep these warnings in mind as a guardrail around my own thought processes, my decision-making process and my own interactions with others.   I also tend to use them as a screen through which I evaluate and adapt to the behaviors of those around me.

While I run across all six of these in everyday life – in attitude, conversation and interaction – I find that an awareness of these warnings is most valuable in the professional parts of my life.  I’ve had the opportunity to work in both the public and private sector – in both small and large organizations – at both for and non-profit organizations – in jobs with both minimal and significant responsibilities.  The setting or circumstances do not matter – these warnings inevitably go unheeded – and many of them can all too often stand out as the source – in one form or another – of individual or organizational failure.  It’s not hard to restate them in a way that makes them relevant to the work environment:

  • No one wins a fight at work – anyone who frames obstacles at work as conflicts that will have a winner and loser has already lost – both professionally and with respect to his responsibility to the employer and his or her colleagues.
  • No employer or supervisor or co-worker is perfect.  There are things about any of these that you’ll like and appreciate and things you won’t.  With respect to the things that you don’t like or appreciate, there will be things about each that you can influence or change and things you can’t.  Learn to distinguish between the two and throw your energy into areas where positive change is possible.  If that’s not enough for you or it leaves you disgruntled or dissatisfied – focused on the negatives that you can’t change – you’re in the wrong place and a decision to stay will only end badly for you – and possibly for others.
  • Don’t limit yourself based on past experience or your own skill set – you’re surrounded by others with skills, capabilities and experiences that only magnify what you’re capable of doing.  So many things become possible that once weren’t when you reach out and pull those around you into the process of solving a problem.  I’ve found – over and over – that I’m almost never the smartest or most capable person in the room.
  • Learn to distinguish between what is and is not truly important.  There will always be things that you believe to be important – critically important – worth fighting for – but by stepping outside yourself and thinking more broadly and inclusively – you’ll often find that they don’t carry the weight you originally thought.  All too often, they spring from personal pride, arrogance or a desire to put yourself at the center of a process.  More projects have died and more deadlines have not been met because one or more of those working on the project simply isn’t capable of letting go of those things that simply aren’t critical to the final outcome.
  • You’ll always be busy, you’ll always have work to do, you’ll never feel like you have the time – but if you don’t carve out opportunities to improve yourself, to learn, to listen, to study – you’ll never be more capable that you are at any given moment – and don’t disregard opportunities to learn from those around you.  As a supervisor, I’ve learned more from my direct reports and from those in organizations that I’ve led than any other source available to me.
  • Forcing a solution based on authority or assuming that a solution imposed over the objections of those impacted will lead to a good outcome usually leads instead either to outright failure or to a lack of adherence and support – slow, gradual failure.  There’s a time for any supervisor to exercise unbridled authority but I find that it’s almost always limited to time-sensitive, crisis situations – where the alternative to making a decision and compelling action is disaster.  Otherwise, take the time to understand concerns and objections, listen to those who will have to either implement or be impacted by a decision, accommodate those concerns or uncertainties to the greatest degree possible and then be open and honest about why everyone is not getting everything they believe they need.

It may seem like I’ve trivialized Cicero’s warnings by focusing on professional considerations.  I do so only because this is where they come to life most vividly for me.  I can assure you that I see far too many instances where these principles are disregarded outside of the workplace – by friends and acquaintances, by educators, by politicians – all too often leading to the same disappointing or damaging outcomes – at times on a mammoth scale.  I’d suggest that failure to heed any one of these warnings has the potential to damage a friendship, a family relationship (spouse, parent, child or sibling) or a reputation in the community.  Still, the purpose of my Pillars is to guide me in the day to day – and all too much of my day to day involves what I do at work.  This is where it usually becomes real for me.

Posted in On My Mind | 4 Comments

Scribbles – Two Tables – 8/4/2018

**Here’s a partial piece I’ve been playing with – hope you enjoy and always open to suggestions or criticisms**

Chapter One – Two Tables

Thinking back on the week, it was hard for her to identify that specific point in time when she’d decided to leave.  Gorion had neither said nor done anything, at least overtly, to communicate his intentions in this regard.  Still, for someone who knew the old man as well as her, the signs had been there.  Understanding had slowly crept up on her, stalked her..transformed itself from suspicion to certitude in such a gradual way that there had been no real moment of realization.  When Gorion had broached the subject last night, it had come to her almost as old news.

After their conversation, despite the lateness of the hour, she had insisted on making the hike out to Cullyn’s lodge.  When she arrived, she had found him gone.  Not surprising.  He often hunted at night – sometimes with her, sometimes alone.  No less painful, however, for it’s predictability.  His absence tonight meant that far too many things would go unsaid.  If Gorion had become the father of her she mind, Cullyn had been the teacher that most are never so lucky to find – the one tending to the health of her soul.  Stepping into his home, letting herself fall into a seat at his table, she couldn’t help but think back on her time with the two of them and forward to a time when they would no longer be part of her days.

Gorion had found her at a very early age, about the time she had begun work in the Keep’s kitchens.  She had been one of the many young girls charged with delivering meals to the scholars in residence.  He had been one of those she’d called on.  His was a small suite in one of the older and more remote sections of the Keep.  He had no furniture to speak of – a table, two chairs, an old pallet – everything piled high with books, maps, scrolls, inks and quills.

He had always been pleasant with her, greeting her, acknowledging her presence in a way so many of the other scholars had not.  It had unnerved her at first.  Over time, however, his pleasantries and good-natured questions about life in the kitchens came to be expected and the two of them drifted into a comfortable and amiable pattern.

So much so that she had eventually found herself asking questions in return.  In later years, they had laughed about her first simple inquiries into the state of the world outside the walls of the Keep, so full of misconception and half-truth.  He would have had every right to meet these tangled queries with arrogant disdain, with pomposity or with amused patronizing silence.  Instead, she remembered him responding with a gentle enthusiasm and a perpetual patience, always working to clear away misunderstandings, to disabuse her of suspicion and to move her towards a more active mental life.

And oh…how he had succeeded.  Every scrap of information he managed to communicate and every silly notion he’d managed to disabuse had only created a greater awareness of her ignorance.  Her visits became lengthier, her questions more focused, their dialogue more interactive.  In the end, she left him with little alternative but to take responsibility for the process he’d started and he sought out Cook with the proposal that she learn to read and write.  The request had been an unprecedented one for Cook, so totally outside of her experience that she assumed Gorion must be having a joke at someone else’s expense, most likely hers.  He persisted, however, and, in the end, she had been given to Gorion as a student.

It was a day that stood out in her memory as a bright, shining line between all that had gone before and all that would come to be.  She passed out of Cook’s world and into Gorion’s.  He had had a corner of the suite cleared and a second small desk brought in.  She had moved from the kitchens to the Apprentices’ Dormitory.  She was still expected to fetch his meals.  In addition, she took responsibility not only for cleaning the suite but for maintaining some semblance of order within his quarters.  In return, he would devote the second half of the day to her instruction.  Her evenings were spent with his books and maps and inks and quills.

For many years, this arrangement worked well for both of them.  While she could lay no claim to brilliance, she did possess a lively intellect and an inquiring and adventurous spirit.  She threw herself into the study of geography, history, literature and languages with a commitment that sometimes amazed her teacher.  For his part, Gorion responded in kind and performed admirably as a teacher.  He nurtured and supported her natural interests while pushing her to acquire a command of those subjects she found less engaging.  At times she struggled…with his help she somehow, always overcame.  Over time, he had helped her to understand that what he was giving her was not just knowledge but control…over herself…her surroundings…those around her.  On the eve of her departure, she was sure that she would be walking into the world with an education superior to most others that she might encounter.

It was the first, but not the most important, of the two gifts he had given her.  More valuable to her by far was the sense of belonging, of proper place, that had gradually come to her during their twenty odd years together.  His world had been a familiar and stable place.  It had also been one steeped in purpose and in principle.  Wrapped within it, she grew, explored her capabilities and limitations, and developed a true sense of self.

Not that she had ever, at least according to Gorion, had much work to do in this regard.  He often commented on the fact that, even as a young one, she had seemed complete, centered to an almost unnatural degree.  It had always been an article of faith for Gorion that people were always either more or less than what they seemed, that what shone through to the outside world was somehow not representative of what lay at the core, within the heart and soul.  With her, he claimed, it was different; that she reflected a consistency, a unique balance between thought, feeling and deed.  It had prompted Gorion to nickname her “Harmony” and to suggest from time to time that hers was one of the oldest souls he had ever touched.

Her relationship with Cullyn, though it had come to be every bit as important, was of an entirely different nature.  No man for unnecessary sentiment, he had never referred to her as anything but “Nubbin”.  She had met him for the first time when he had visited Gorion in his suite, to discuss Gorion’s request for assistance with a line of research he’d been pursuing.  She’d sat at her desk and watched, observing him as he listened impassively to Gorion discuss the nature of his need.  He wasn’t old but he was worn, like a good pair of leather boots that hadn’t been properly cared for, still serviceable and with many good years remaining but scuffed, dried and cracked.  He had said almost nothing, asked no questions, but had ended the conversation with a brief statement of willingness to help, then quickly excused himself.

Several days afterwards, she and Gorion had walked out to his lodge, a solid but unassuming place he had built for himself about an hour’s walk from the walls of the Keep.  Cullyn had met them at the door but had not asked them in.  Gorion attempted to strike up a conversation but had not been able to push past Cullyn’s first few grudging pleasantries.  Gorion eventually handed Cullyn a leather pouch – one she assumed had been filled with coin.  As part of an equally forced farewell, Gorion had explained to Cullyn that she would thereafter be calling on him in his stead.

It had started simply, weekly visits at age seven to pick up parcels for Gorion.  Now at 17, sitting in his chair and thinking back, she grinned at the memories of those initial visits.  He would always be waiting for her, sitting on his stoop, usually at work on a shaft or repairing one of his bows.  Always met with that simple greeting, “Hello Nubbin, what have you for me today?”  She would pay him, thank him for whatever parcel he had prepared and be on her way.  He would return to his work with a nod and a quick “Next week then, Nubbin.”

And so it had gone on for over six months, until she had arrived one afternoon to find him gone.  She had walked around the lodge, looking for him but also allowing herself for the first time to examine the drying stands, the smoker, the racks of antlers hung under the eaves.  To the rear of his lodge, she had found a covered work area.  While it was currently open to the weather on all sides, she noticed that it had been constructed so as to allow wood panels to be hung as protection against inclement weather.  Under the roof she found racks of tools for working wood, a number of oak and ash staves which had been laid out for curing, several bows in various stages of construction or repair.  The scene somehow resonated with her and she couldn’t help but reach out to one of the bows.  Not ornate, not by any stretch of the imagination, but beautiful nonetheless.  The wood was smooth, carefully carved and formed, almost warm to the touch…and then he was there, a hand on her shoulder and a quick, “Careful Nubbin, not quite ready for that one yet.”

That was all.  They had walked around to the front together, she had paid him and he had surrendered another wrapped bundle.  She thanked him, as she always had and turned to begin the trip home.  This time, however, he surprised her by saying “Tomorrow then, Nubbin.”  She chose not to turn or acknowledge the break in their pattern but on her way home, but for the first time in over six months, chose to open the pouch he had provided.  It was filled with sand…nothing more.  That evening, Gorion had informed her that he would not be available for lessons the following afternoon and that she was free to use the time as she would.  It was all he’d needed to say.  She had understood and been delighted.

A new routine quickly developed that would bind them all for the better part of ten years.  For the first four days of the week, she would work with Gorion, delving ever deeper into the realms of languages, geography, history, mathematics and alchemy.  The final three days of the week were spent with Cullyn.  It had started simply with short walks in the woods at his side.  There had always been an objective…to harvest mushrooms, nuts, wild honey or tubers…to choose and cut the staves Cullyn used in his work…to clear and reset traps…to check trout lines.  It was warm, wonderful, sunny work that she reveled in…seeming at first like a carefree vacation from her time laboring away at the desk in Gorion’s chamber.  As her first days with Cullyn stretched into months, however, she grew to realize that he had become every bit as much a teacher as Gorion…the only difference being the classroom over which he presided and the style by which he shared what he knew.

His classroom was every part of the world not bound by walls.  She went out with him every day…no matter the season or the weather…moving quietly at his side…struggling at times to stay apace…always alert and ready to receive those bits of woodcraft that he so casually dispensed.

TO BE CONTINUED…

Posted in Scribbles | 8 Comments